Refusal of the Call is a temporarily hesitation or complete refusal of the call. It can appear only in the beginning or throughout the entire story. The main function of this stage is to redirect the focus of the adventure. Also, the hesitation allows the audience to be aware of the challenges ahead for the hero.
Meeting with the Mentor is the stage in the Hero's Journey where he gains the supplies, knowledge, and confidence needed to overcome fear and commit to the adventure. The function of this stage is to provide the hero with something he/she needs for the journey: whether it be advise, magical gifts, or testing. At some point in the story, if no apparent Mentor has been cast, one of the character has to wear the mask of the Mentor archetype. Lastly, the Mentor shines light on the reality that everyone has to learn the lessons of life.
Crossing the First Threshold is when the Hero fully commits to the adventure. Signifies we have reached the border of the Ordinary World and the Special World. This stages combines the external and internal choices that puts the story in motion past the Threshold Guardian. Whose 'responsibilities' are to block the hero's way and to train them in preparation for their adventure. It is the Hero's job to find his/her way around the Threshold Guardian.
It is my belief that Vogler places these three stages in consecutive order because they each lead to the next stage. For most of the other stages it seems that they can be molded together or mixed around in a different manner to tell a certain story. However, these three seem to be very connected. The hero overcomes his fear by meeting with the mentor, and by doing so over comes his fear which leads him/her to the first threshold of the journey.
In the section where Vogler talks about Mentors like parents and how an overprotective Mentor (parent) can lead to a tragic situation. This reminds me of the relationship that my best friend and her mother have, which can be seen as a love-hate relationship. Her mother is very overbearing, always wanting to know who she is with, what she is doing, where she is going. This type of overprotectiveness is what Vogler stated as being obsessed with the hero. For my friend, she feels the need to revolt against her mother just so she can breath. The relationship they have is leading down the wrong path or as Vogler puts it 'can lead to tragic situations.'
Some Questions to Think About....
1. If the Hero automatically accepts the call to adventure what do you believe would happen to the refusal? Would there still be one?
2. Can you think of any movies where there is no apparent Mentor? How does the hero learn lessons if there is none?
3. Who have been Mentors and Threshold Guardians in your life? Have they been positive or negative? Why?